Indeed's FUBAR UX


"Indeed gives zero fucks about employers!!! - Yes, that's a quote from an employer... and No you're not surprised.


What do you get when you cross Indeed desperation with Facebook hubris and throw in a dash of Google humility?

This week's podcast, of course. What's more?

As always, your favorite podcast is made possible by Jobvite, JobAdX, and Sovren.

PODCAST TRANSCRIPTION sponsored by:

Disability Solutions helps forward thinking employers create world class hiring and retention programs for people with disabilities.


INTRO (1s):

Hide your kids! Lock the doors! You're listening to HR’s most dangerous podcast. Chad Sowash and Joel Cheeseman are here to punch the recruiting industry, right where it hurts! Complete with breaking news, brash opinion and loads of snark, buckle up boys and girls, it's time for the Chad and Cheese podcast.

Joel (21s):

Oh yeah. The least you're not in Texas, unless you are in Texas. In which case? Ouch. Welcome to the Chad and Cheese podcast. Everybody. I'm your cohost, Joel "blame it on the windmills" Cheeseman


Chad (37s):

and I'm Chad "rolling blackout" Sowash.


Joel (41s):

And on this week, show Australia tells Google that's not a knife, that's a knife. Chad gets a chubby listening to Spotify and indeed proves once again that it quote "gives zero fucks about employers" end quote, we'll be right back after I finished shoveling my God damn driveway.


Sovren (1m 3s):

You already know that Sovren makes the world's best resume CV parser, but did you know that Sovren also makes the world's best AI matching engine? Only Sovren's AI matching engine goes beyond the buzzwords. With Sovren you control how the engine thinks with every match the Sovren engine tells you what matched and exactly how each matching document was scored. And if you don't agree with the way it's scored the matches, you can simply move some sliders to tell it, to score the matches your way. No other engine on earth gives you that combination of insight and control. With Sovren, matching isn't some frustrating "black box, trust us, it's magic, one shot deal" like all the others. No, with Sovren, matching is completely understandable, completely controllable, and actually kind of fun. Sovren ~ software so human you'll want to take it to dinner.


Joel (2m 2s):

Good times.


Chad (2m 7s):

Welcome to America kids. The land of a rolling blackouts. What the fuck is going on, dude?


Joel (2m 13s):

Well, dude, I was sipping margaritas and hunting Marlin in the keys this early this week. So I got to leave that and come home to like a foot of snow. So I'm a little bit salty and not from the margaritas I had.


Chad (2m 27s):

Yeah, I think people in Texas are probably a little bit more pissed than you are right now.


Joel (2m 34s):

It's funny. You mentioned that because my father lives in Texas and he's still in route to get back to Texas. He lives in Austin. He has to go to Houston, which I guess apparently is thawing out quicker than the rest of the state. And then he has to go home. I'm not sure when he'll get to go home, how the roads are and whatnot. And then he gets to find out if his pipes burst or not, he's still a cold weather guy at heart, but he may or may not have electricity and keep in mind. He's 81. So yeah, life is going to be real fun for him this weekend.


Chad (3m 3s):

I'd be fucking pissed if I were a Texan, because we're talking about a state that is number eight in the GDP, worldwide. Prides themselves in being the quote/unquote "Energy state" and all forms of Texas Energy failed. I mean, I, I don't know where they fuck where'd they buy those windmills that they buy them from fucking Mattel. I mean, I don't get it here in good old Hicksville of Indiana. We have fields of windmills and those motherfuckers are cranking out megawatts. They've been doing it for years. I just can't get it. And again, being a Texan and obviously they don't pay taxes.


Chad (3m 47s):

They, obviously want, they want to have low energy costs. And I think overall it's like, guys, you gotta pay for something somehow. Fuck.


Joel (4m 1s):

And I know that we talk football on the show quite a bit. And football season is over. And our international listeners hate when we talk football, football fans will remember when the Superbowl was in Dallas a few years ago and they had this same shit happen. So not only do they say, you know, fuck it. They don't apparently learn from the past and try to fix shit. But there's another winter front coming this weekend. It's not going to get much easier anytime sooner for Texas. Shout out Texas. We love you man. No matter what, dude, are you ready for this?


Chad (4m 32s):

What?


Joel (4m 32s):

Okay. We love Torchy's speaking of Texas. I mean love Torchy's right. So I'm talking about, we're talking about Torchy's with my sister who lives in Jeffersonville, Indiana. Sorry to get so Metta everybody, but okay. So we talked Torchy's and my sister goes, Oh, I think there's a, Torchy's moving into Jeffersonville, which is a small town of about 50,000 people. It's near Louisville, Kentucky, which is not a big city either. And it's a long way from Texas. And I'm like, get the fuck outta here. This is not, it's a different Torchy's or it's tortures or you're, you're getting it wrong. So I go to Torchy's website, I go to locations and I search Indiana. And Holy fuck.


Joel (5m 13s):

There's a Torchy's Tacos moving to Jeffersonville. So I, my friend will be tracking down to Jeff at least three or four, six, 10 times a year just to get some Torchy's Tacos. And I'm fingers crossed that they're coming to Indianapolis soon.


Chad (5m 30s):

There's just something about sitting in Austin and having a Torchy's Tacos. I think it's going to be entirely different being in Jeff, having a Torchy's Tacos.


Joel (5m 42s):

It's just a different kind of trashy. It's a different kind of trashy when you get the extra sauce on that taco.


Chad (5m 48s):

Yeah. Okay. I will take that.


Joel (5m 50s):

It's way better than the Taco Bell on taste. I'm telling you that, right?


Chad (5m 54s):

God, I fucking hope so. Shout out to Daniel Fellows from get optimal. Who sent me some French gin.


Joel (6m 2s):

And sent me nothing by the way. Thanks Dan. .


Chad (6m 5s):

You don't deserve anything.


Joel (6m 7s):

I'm not worthy.


Chad (6m 8s):

Here's the thing though. I got sent the gin. Julie confiscated the gin. All I have now is I can taste her gin when she's having cocktails, because it's obviously fucking good. So yeah. Thanks. Thanks Daniel. If you could send another package, that'd be great. Thank you.


Joel (6m 25s):

Are you a gin guy now? I'm a little confused. Or do they sell, do not sell whiskey in his part of England?


Chad (6m 32s):

Daniel is a different kind of guy. He doesn't just want to give you what you want. He wants to give you something that is outside of your comfort zone. And no, I'm not a gin guy. And he's like, you will love this gin and Daniel, I bet I would love that gin, if my wife didn't steal it.


Joel (6m 50s):

Speaking of women who like liquor, shout out to my sister who got remarried on Valentine's Day. How romantic is that? She did tie the knot. I know I mentioned I was going, but it, it did. She closed the deal. It was done. And she is soon to be Holly Bricker.


Chad (7m 8s):

Very nice.


Joel (7m 9s):

On her ID in case you are looking for her on, I don't know, Snapchat or something. Yeah.


Chad (7m 15s):

Nothing, nothing like sending, sending people out to troll your, your sister. That's awesome.


Joel (7m 20s):

Yeah. She's not on Snapchat or anything else, I think.


Chad (7m 23s):

In case you missed it, we interviewed Torin Ellis on the pod this week, check it out. It's called exercising our demons. And there's more Torin to come. We did like an hour or something with them. So I cut it up into, into short bite sized clips and I've already had people saying, Hey, that was too short. So don't worry. There's more coming.


Joel (7m 46s):

Yes. Oh man. I enjoy being in the punching bag on those podcasts. So thanks everybody for asking for more Torin. That's great. That's great. I appreciate it. Well, speaking of saltiness, you're mad at Kroger again, aren't you?


Chad (7m 59s):

Kroger, again is shutting down two locations this time in Seattle, the last one was in Southern California, because they are being forced. That's right. Kids forced to pay their essential workers, $4 more an hour. And again, I would like to remind everyone we're talking about people who, if you don't have them working, hence essential workers, the shit doesn't get done. They're the people who look you in the eye and say, thank you for shopping here every day. Right. But yet, but yet the fucking CEO makes $14 million.


Chad (8m 40s):

And we're talking about revenues, Kroger revenues overall corporate wide. It was like $121 billion. So when somebody says to me, Oh yeah, but grocery profit margins are really thin. Fuck you. Okay. $14 million then fuck you. Anyway.


Joel (8m 60s):

So that means the Sowash boycott is still on Kroger and well, I've got a new boycott of my own. I think speaking of mad. Word out this week, BK, Burger King is changing the chicken sandwich and I'm tired of this movement of Popeye's, Chick-fil-A, the original chicken sandwich at Burger King was one of the reasons I fell in love with Burger King and they're changing the damn chicken sandwich. I got a problem with that Chad, but I'm going to taste it first before I give a final verdict.


Chad (9m 32s):

I actually reached out to Ellie Doty, who is the CMO of Burger King. And I asked her if we could do like a taste test because they also, I think a Popeye's as a sister. Yeah. Sister franchise, if we could do a taste test. And I think that you would definitely be in for that. So hopefully, you know, we can get that done.


Joel (9m 51s):

A little date with you for some chicken sandwiches at BK. That sounds good. Sounds good. Bring on the coupons. Bring on the coupons, Ellie.


Chad (10m 1s):

I'm ready. Excellent. Real quick. We have in a event, that's a TNG an ADA digital that's right, those crazy kids from Sweden. They're having a Digital Unbiased Day on a March 18th. Just go to TNG.SE, scroll down to the wonderful looking painted lady and register. So some of your favorite people from TNG and ADA digital will be speaking ASA, Sarah, Elan, plus my lovely wife, Julie, Bass van de Haterd and I'll be speaking as well. So get in there, register, and we'll see you soon!


Joel (10m 43s):

Nice by the way. Speaking of Sweden. And I've got a quick, a Netflix movie recommendation. It's called Red Dot. Yes. It would be like if a Quentin Tarantino redirected Deliverance in Sweden. Oh, that's all I'm going to say. Okay. Well, I'm going to say if that sounds appealing to you, Red Dot on Netflix and you're welcome.


Chad (11m 3s):

It's on my watch list.


Joel (11m 5s):

There you go.


Chad (11m 5s):

Don't forget if you want free beer. That AdZuna is propping up kids. Free t-shirts that Emissary is a place where you go to do text recruiting, is propping up free t-shirts or free whiskey. That's right. We're giving away free shit left and right, because Sovren, Sovren loves you go to Chadcheese.com, click on free, or just go Chadcheese.com/free and register. And we give shit away, because our listeners deserve free shit.


Joel (11m 38s):

Yeah. Sovereign loves you, but they hate your liver apparently. Let's get to some topics shall we?


Chad (11m 45s):

Topics!


Joel (11m 46s):

Let's pile on Indeed to start the show. What better way to feel the love? What better way to feel the love? So you got some, some, some, some mad users, but you got some UX issues with what Indeed's doing right now.


Chad (12m 1s):

So remember when Indeed changed their entire user interface and model a few years ago, they used to be like Google, not Google for Jobs, but Google, when you would click on the job link, it would take you to the corporate career site where you, I mean, just directly.


Joel (12m 19s):

Like a search engine.


Chad (12m 20s):

Yeah. Like search engine.


Joel (12m 22s):

Yeah. I remember those days.


Chad (12m 24s):

Then they changed their user interface entirely, where you click on the job title, then it opens the job description on Indeed. So you can view it there. Then you click apply. Then you go to the corporate career center. So that just, that takes you to two clicks. What they just did is they created an inter-digital page that says, no, Hey, before you leave, make sure you've registered with Indeed. So this interstitial creates a three click obstacle for a candidate to apply on the corporate career site. Number one, view the job on Indeed. Number two, click apply on Indeed version of the job description.


Chad (13m 7s):

And then number three, you have to click. No, thanks on that fucking interstitial. You finally made it kids and Indeed are the one. Remember Indeed was, Oh, they're always talking about like traffic quality and content and


Joel (13m 21s):

We're not NASCAR.


Chad (13m 24s):

We don't do that because we're clean. We're easy. We're simple. We're the best user experience for a job seeker. Well, that's all gone to shit kids.


Joel (13m 34s):

Is Indeed double-dipping? That's what it sounds like. They're getting paid the click and then they're getting the user. They're getting their double dipping and those motherfuckers. I tell you why I got a problem. I'm going to pile on their super bowl ad God dammit, cause it's been a week. So the verdict's out, this ad sucks. It was in the middle of the pack in terms of scoring. I haven't seen the fricking ad since the super bowl and granted we're not in the biggest market in the world. So if you are seeing this ad a lot, please hashtag has Chadcheese. So I can, I can see what's going on. But if, if YouTube is any guide of the success of this ad or this video they've had roughly 250,000 views, which kind of is sucky anyway.


Joel (14m 16s):

But to put that in, in comparison, Fiverr, whose ad was nothing to write home about either has had 7 million views on YouTube. So Indeed hasn't even cracked a million and, or has seven million. That means your ad sucks. No one wants to watch it. No one wants to share it. No one wants to talk about it. Just throw it in the trash, chalk it up as a Mulligan and move on Indeed.


Chad (14m 38s):

And then I've got one more as we pile on, we actually had an employer send us Indeed hate mail. And let me, let me open it up. I'm going to go ahead and read it for you. Okay. Here it is.


Joel (14m 51s):

I like the sound effect. That's good. Like you really have a letter.


Chad (14m 55s):

I'm opening my email right now.


Joel (14m 57s):

Are you David Letterman right now? Your mail.


Chad (15m 1s):

Indeed gives zero fucks about employers, three exclamation marks. They do no product management and when you do provide feedback, it goes nowhere. I look forward to watching them tank for that reason" end quote.


Joel (15m 19s):

So it was a, it was a love letter is what you're saying. It was a love letter that you just opened.


Chad (15m 24s):

Again, this is the sentiment that is out there. It is been out there and it's just getting worse. And if recruitment ad agencies who control a huge amount of spend, if they don't do something about who the fuck is?


Joel (15m 40s):

You know, who else gives zero fucks about employers? Let's talk about Facebook for a second. Shall we? So this is a mean show. Okay. So we got word it's sort of official. We've talked about it. It's been speculated on, but Facebook are scraping apparently sites that have not given permission, which doesn't surprise anybody that's been going on for a long time. But we had a quote come in. This is being tracked now people in their Google analytics or analytics program are seeing basically referral traffic from Facebook. Now this is a reader said, quote, "Facebook are scraping our site and company pages, indexing it to Facebook jobs. They are using the same schema as Google and they are going hard.


Joel (16m 22s):

We have no relationship with Facebook at all. They are doing it all themselves. So the bot doesn't declare itself, but it's been going at it for over a month." This sounds like a porno. Okay. And then on Friday night we started getting large amounts of traffic from Facebook. Okay, well that's nice. The spike perfectly matched this unknown scraper we were tracking. So Facebook is going in without telling people what's going on, but then people are getting great traffic. Good thing, bad thing, indifferent?


Chad (16m 51s):

None of this makes sense to me to be quite frank. I mean, seriously. If Facebook wants to go all in on jobs, then great. Do a pilot with companies with big brands, then release information and data and Harold, how awesome it is. I mean, it's like their PR team has no idea how to work optics. And, we're not just talking about jobs. You're talking about anything fucking Facebook does. The optics for Facebook right now is for shit.


Joel (17m 28s):

Yeah. Facebook has bigger issues to deal about a deal with which we'll get to in a second. But marketplace has been a strong suit for them for quite a while. They've dabbled in this jobs thing, the Slack competitor thing. Clearly there they're getting feedback from data, that marketplace is spiking. I assume with COVID that people trying to sell stuff on marketplace buying stuff because it's cheaper. So you're getting a lot more eyeballs to marketplace in some genius there said, Hey, if we just like have more jobs, we're going to get a lot more views, which means a lot more advertising, which means a lot more money. So this makes total sense from a Facebook, like let's just get more eyeballs standpoint. I'm guessing that most people that are getting scraped, don't give a shit as long as they're still getting traffic, they're not paying for it.


Joel (18m 12s):

Now at some point, Facebook might charge or upgrade jobs or boost them as part of the scraping service. But for me, it's just a par for the course, Facebook is going to do what Facebook is going to do, and it's going to take your jobs and it's going to make money from them.


Chad (18m 26s):

As we just finished talking about the, the serious, fucked up goodness of Indeed. If Facebook starts to do that, I mean, companies are looking for alternatives. That's all there is to it. They don't want to use Indeed. It feels like they have to at this point, so they're looking for alternatives. If Google does go, pay-per-click on Google for Jobs. If Facebook does ramp this up and then start the ability for targeting with jobs. I mean, those are two aspects of get me the fuck away from Indeed that companies I guarantee you will gravitate toward because they hate Facebook and Google less.


Joel (19m 8s):

Yeah. And don't think that these moves aren't like on Indeed's windshield when they're figuring out what the fuck do we do. And by the way, dropping 10, 15, whatever million on a Superbowl ad is part of that panic. And this is the stuff that we're seeing with Google and Facebook, because this stuff is coming and Indeed sees it. And part of this grab of, of candidates is part of like, well, fuck it. We're getting the traffic. We're going to try to get as many of those people into our database as possible so that we can milk them for as long as we possibly can. t


Chad (19m 37s):

As we talk about Google, we talk about Facebook. We're also talking about Australia.


Joel (19m 42s):

Oh, we love Australia.


Chad (19m 43s):

And Australia, Australia has stiffen their spine and said, no, you're not taking our shit, Google, Facebook, fuck you. You're going to pay for the content. And it seems like Google folded.


Joel (20m 0s):

Yeah. When you live in the country, that has 90% of the world's venomous like animals, you really don't give a shit when Google threatens you with shutting down. By the way, never compare Australia to California because that really is an insult, apparently, I pissed off a lot of Australians when I made that comparison. But yeah, so Google kind of played chicken with the government of Australia. Google has about 95% of the market share of search in Australia, roughly 25 million users of the service, again about size of California. But anyway, Google blinked, they said, okay, we understand this is what's going to happen. They understand data that people use their site for new search, that they want to get information that's, news-related, that's solid, you know, journalistic content.


Joel (20m 48s):

And they said, we were going to lose this fight. And we just have to come to terms with the fact that the hundreds of millions, if not billions, and maybe even bigger than that over the last couple of decades that we've been fleecing, newspapers and newspaper content is finally coming to a head and we're going to have to pay the Piper. This is what happens. I love the fact that Rupert Murdoch is kind of behind this. And I'm sure that he's been wanting to stick it to Google for a long time, but he's going to start getting checks from them, which I don't think he's gotten since Google was my was Google was MySpace is search engine and pay them a lot of money to do that back in the day. So this is sort of the reality that Google faces they're either going to pay or they're going to be out of business.


Joel (21m 32s):

And if they don't play companies like Bing and search engines like Yandex and Baidu are eventually going to move in and try and chip away at Google's dominance. So what I think is interesting is look, every country on the planet is going to do this. Like as soon as Google folded, like Canada started, you know, getting all chesty. Europe is going to get super in line to get money from Google, whether or not the US does it, I don't know. Maybe eventually I think they have more lobbyists than most States in Washington. Google does. So they'll hold that off as long as possible. And now Facebook is in the crosshairs.


Joel (22m 13s):

Facebook for the most part has said, suck it. And they have very different business models. I don't think as many people go to Facebook for news as they do pictures of family and other stuff. And I don't know how this works, where if I want to share something from news site a does Google or does Facebook say, sorry, you can't share that. Can you not share any news? Obviously that's a little bit frustrating. Facebook probably will pay in the end somehow. Yeah.


Chad (22m 41s):

Well, Google understands that if they step away, there's going to be a vacuum and they don't want that. And so they're playing the long game and they're playing smart, not to mention, they have mountains of fucking money for God sakes and they negotiated and I guarantee you, they negotiated a good deal. Facebook is painting themselves into a corner, unless they follow suit. So overall great job Australia! Way to stiffen the spine everybody's watching you. And hopefully everybody else will follow suit because content has worth.


Joel (23m 14s):

Yeah, for sure. Look, journalists have been taking it in the, you know what, for two, for 20 some years, thanks to the decline in classified revenue and the cheapening and commoditization of journalism. So the world will probably be better off by newspapers, making more money and being able to pay better journalists. My question is newspapers used to rule the world in regards to classified advertising does this inflow of money and better journalism, increase subscriptions, increase eyeballs and thus bring back more companies and employers to online newspapers. I got to think it does, right?


Chad (23m 52s):

Yeah. I'm with you.


Joel (23m 55s):

All right, man. Let's take a quick break and we'll get to acquisitions and all kinds of good stuff. We'll get a little less salty I think.


JobAdX (24m 2s):

Whether you're struggling to fill high volume, hourly roles or looking for long-term full time talent, your recruiting toolkit needs to be lean and mean as you adjust with fewer resources, tighter budgets and rapid hiring needs in a saturated and competitive market. Posting jobs, shouldn't be a lengthy, risky or fruitless process. You can count on JobAdX to be your force maximizer. Automate the details of your programmatic job ad distribution candidate targeting and budget management so you can focus your energy on the big picture and human aspects of recruiting top talent. Reach relevant candidates effortlessly across 200 sites in the U S and Canada. Simply upload a feed of your jobs and set your budget in less than five minutes. We do the rest. Getting an influx of applicants already that just aren't the right fit? JobAdX presents your jobs to targeted candidates based on their job preferences to get granular.


JobAdX (24m 44s):

Now your advertising spend can go towards more relevant candidates, not just more applicants. What's more your JobAdX programmatic campaigns now reach for government job bank systems in over 30 States, giving you centralized access to the majority of active job seekers, eager to get off of unemployment and get back to work. Send us a note today with your unique challenge, to see how we can help you in the new state of recruiting, make the next step forward and start your results focused campaign now at JobAdX.com that's JobAdX.com.


Chad (25m 2s):

Out of the break I have, I've got breaking news. I just received a message from Recruit X. It seems like Recruit X has acquired Reverse Delta, including their FX Recruiter career site platform. I have no clue who these people are, but it sounds like a match.


Joel (25m 22s):

Sounds like a match.


Chad (25m 24s):

Yeah. So we're going to have to check this out, but yes, it RecruitX acquires Reverse Delta. Interesting. Very interesting.


Joel (25m 33s):

And we just had drinks with James Deneen. How could he not give us the scoop on that? That's some bullshit. Thanks James. Thanks James. Well, don't call it an acquisition, apparently.


Chad (25m 44s):

It's a matchup.


Joel (25m 45s):

Recruitee yeah. Acquired. This is kind of a weird, a weird deal


Chad (25m 50s):

From the Netherlands. Of course, it's weird.


Joel (25m 54s):

Obviously it's the Nordics! Amsterdam based Recruitee is combining with Helsinki based provider of core HR software in the Nordics to quote, "create a premium digital HR solutions offering the combined group will have over 4,000 customers across Europe and the U S and a team of over 250 employees, PSG leading growth equity firm, partnering with B2B software companies will back the business as the majority shareholder following its investment in Sympa in July of 2020," the CEO clarifies that this is neither a merger nor an acquisition. They just want to keep, they want to keep both companies separate here because they actually serve different regions and different customers.


Joel (26m 37s):

The combined group aims to achieve unicorn status. We'll see about that in the next to six years and become quote, "one of the biggest global HR tech companies around" high aspirations in the Nordics.


Chad (26m 52s):

Oh yeah. I mean, they've got, I mean, it sounds like they've got some really good growth going on. Private equity is they're buying shit up, kids and PSG obviously saw that this startup kind of up, up and coming ATS Recruitee they're obviously gaining traction, looking at just some of the functionality